Wheelie spies

Rather than wait for an interesting story to come along, the Poorhouse thought we'd go with a laugh-at-stupid-people type snippet to do with bins...but in doing so perhaps opened a non-recyclable can of worms.

Wheelie bins may have been around for god knows how many years, but apparently they still hold the fear and mystique of strange new alien technology for some. So much so, that Epping Forest council is running roadshows to demonstrate how to use them. One might think that something in the shape of a bin with a big obvious lid and wheels on its base might be rather self explanatory, but according to the Telegraph via the New Statesman, people "will be able to see test runs by council officers who will explain the new technology". Further more, rubbish neophytes will get "to see samples and find out how easy they are to move", the aim being to "relieve [newcomer's] fears". Binophobia? It's just too easy to laugh.

However further investigation reveals that perhaps there is something to be slightly scared of after all.

Unbeknownst to many, the Government has been rather covertly putting wireless bugs in at least half a million wheelie bins. For many people, despite it having potential consequences for the individual and presumably coming out of the public purse, it wasn't until the Mail on Sunday broke the story that it came to light. Yes, it was the Mail, but it seems that it is actually true for a change - although in true ignorant racist Mail style they of course had to run with the headline "Germans plant bugs in our wheelie bins".

For what it's worth, the Germanic reference was nothing to do with the descent of our royal family who Mail readers probably quite like, but rather it so happens that the bin-sensors are largely being made by German firms.

So, the purpose of the bin bug? These are small RFID chips inserted under the lid of the bin which transmit a unique serial number. You can easily identify if you have one simply by looking for a small round battery-looking thing at the front of the underside of your bin lid. For now, the deal seems to be that your bin will be emptied by a bin lorry especially equipped with a RFID reader. Upon lifting it to be emptied, the serial number of your bin will be recorded along with the weight of its contents - i.e. an approximation of how much rubbish you are throwing away. This information is then transmitted to a central database.

The point of it all so far is a little ambiguous. Some councils have made the claim that it is there simply to resolve arguments between neighbours about whose bin is whose. The Poorhouse finds this quite laughable insomuch as a quick dab of a paintbrush would do the same at a lesser cost and allow a rather quicker more convenient detection scheme than bringing down someone with a chip reader.

A different council came up with a different (and better) excuse for the same thing, saying basically that it would allow the identification of areas who throw an unusually high amount of things away and hence probably aren't doing their best with regard to recycling. Some sort of pro-recycling education could then be targeted their way. This is a potentially rather laudable scheme but it seems that if true it has been gone about in a rather suspiciously covert way.

Most definitely each bin can be uniquely identified, so the potential is there to act on information about individuals. The feelings of the Mail and many others is that it is a precursor to a new tax on rubbish - hilariously dubbed "Pay as you throw" and "Chip and bin". Perhaps those of us who throw more than x amount of stuff away as opposed to recycling it will have to pay more for our bins to be collected. The selfish right wing is of course incandescent about the prospect of having to pay for doing above average damage to the environment.

The Poorhouse feels more charitably towards that particular idea. Pay per usage - as opposed to a flat proportion of the council tax - may well be the incentive people need to recycle and reuse more, and throw away less. Of course there are huge issues in terms of sneaking stuff in other people's bins and so on, but maybe a vaguely coherent scheme could be put together in time. It would of course be nice for certain councils to make recycling easier to do before going to these rather extreme measures first but hey, where common sense, environmental sensibility and decency fail it would be nice to fantasise that the invisible hand of market forces - which to be fair usually seem to cause the exact sort of mass-consumption problems that make vast and largely needless amounts of non-degradable rubbish in the first place - could be a force for good.

Where it could however become ever more Big Brother is when more and more shop-bought items coming with their own RFID chips in them. Famously, Gillette have been known to put such chips in their razor's packaging which has unnerved some people enough already. But once you've bought your razors and thrown away the packaging into your bin it would be easy enough - if someone found it desirable - for the bin lorry to detect exactly what that bit of rubbish was and how much of it there was and log it into their central database. Whilst it's hard to describe a bunch of rotting trash as a marketer's dream, there is potential commercial usage in such information one supposes, for behaviour monitoring, promotional targeting and so on.

For the more paranoid amongst you even in these pre universal-RFID days, Andrew Pelling MP (Tory), has suggested that burglars could hack into the database to analyse your recent waste quantity and determine if you were on holiday or not.


Comments

Scary Stuff

Anyway, have you eaten the raisin yet?

damnit

Oopsy, still not eaten the raisin. I never remember to do so when hunger strikes, and I feel I need to wait for a clean tongue and an empty stomach to do it justice. Or that's my excuse.

THIS WEEKEND!???

Bin Bugs and more!

This unsolicited and unwarranted invasion of our privacy caused much outrage, some months ago now, in the Nantwich Chronicle. At the time, close inspection revealed that we, ourselves, were bug-free.
Coincidently, a few days before the news on Wheelie Spies hit the Poorhouse, I was carrying out my usual pre-Christmas wheelie bin wash (to minimise bugs of an altogether different kind). Has anyone worked out the best order of cleaning a wheelie bin that avoids merely transferring dirt from one side, the bottom or a wheel to the next? Surely committees should be set up and research projects launched into such a time- (and water-)wasting exercise?
Anyway, I discovered that we now have "tagged" green (category 1 paper) and grey (category 2 paper, plastic bottles and tins) bins. Will the bugs still work now they have been liberally hosed down or might I have inactivated them? As a result of zealous bin-pride, will we be targetted as failing to reach a reasonable quota of recycling?
Are the things radioactive (they are pretty much the size of a 2p-piece)? Should I check with NHS Direct as to whether I need screening for exposure to Polonium or, since you tell me they are German, not Russian, will all be well?
As panic abates, I find mysef wondering: given the interest in my recyclables, why doesn't anyone want to know about my black bin - the real, smelly, must-tie-it-up-in-a bag-so-it-can't-escape-between-collections rubbish? Wouldn't percentages be more useful than absolute values?
Incidentally, a Road Show, leaflet or interactive video covering "Caring for your Wheelie Bin" might be a handy (typically environmentally-unfriendly) addition to a system which, when you buy the relevant container, subjects you to regular, apparently unstoppable, printed mail-drops on developments in and accessories for composting!

Did it make front page of

Did it make front page of the Nantwich Chronicle?? Presumably not being about yobs (or not the right sort of yobs), charities or roads it did not - although perhaps the save the road committee rebranded to Save Our Bins?

As to how to wash a bin, it seems it's hard. Google says there are plenty of companies to do it for you, or if you feel you are now adept there are a surprisingly high amount of franchise opportunities, Green Clean to take one at random. For instructions, well, probably mostly trade secrets, but Wheelie Clean (haha) Bins has brief description of the heavy industrial equipment you should use.

I am shocked to hear of your tagging, tho like you I can't quite see the (legitimate) point in bugging just the recyclables. I suppose they could detect if you never used it, but unless they tie it up with census type info (maybe they do) how are they to know how many of you, your demographic, your lifestyle etc. to see if you are good green people? I feel they are probably fine to be washed (unless you want to "wash" them with say a blowtorch) especially if they are indeed the menace to society that some portray them as. I think reports have stated quite some potential legal threatening against citizens who decide they are going to rid themselves of the bugs so you might be playing with fire to bleach them too hard.

I assume the pro compost paper is nice and glossy and hence unsuitable for even considering composting.